MSCI operating assets test could eject Strategy, paper says
A Bitcoin Policy Institute paper says MSCI's proposed screen for non-operating companies could remove Strategy, Metaplanet and Yellow Cake from its indexes, with a decision due by 16 October.
Why it matters: MSCI's decision could force index-tracking funds to sell billions of dollars of Strategy shares, and the paper says the proposed test could reach beyond crypto to other capital-intensive companies.
Key points
- MSCI's simulated deletions include Strategy, Metaplanet and uranium holder Yellow Cake.
- JPMorgan estimated MSCI-linked funds could sell about $2.8bn of Strategy shares, rising to $8.8bn if other index providers followed.
- The paper says 'operating assets' is not defined under US GAAP or IFRS, and MSCI is expected to decide on or before 16 October.
MSCI's proposed test for non-operating companies could eject Strategy, Metaplanet and Yellow Cake from major indexes, according to a new paper from the Bitcoin Policy Institute. The Washington-based think tank published the 23-page analysis by executive director Conner Brown on Wednesday, Bitcoin.com News reports.
The paper sets out the scale of index providers' influence. Index funds held $21.8tn, or 53.9% of US long-term fund assets, as of July, against $18.6tn in actively managed funds, and MSCI says $21tn is benchmarked to its indexes. JPMorgan analysts estimated that removing Strategy could prompt roughly $2.8bn in selling by MSCI-tracking funds, rising to $8.8bn if other index providers followed. MSCI dropped an earlier proposal that excluded companies whose digital assets were at least 50% of total assets, then froze share-count increases and deferred new additions.
Its August proposal instead asks whether a company has enough operating assets. Brown argues operating assets is not a standardised balance-sheet category under US GAAP or IFRS, leaving MSCI to classify cash, mineral rights, unfinished construction and intellectual property.
Brown also examines Strategy's Bitcoin accounting, noting $22.8bn in Bitcoin-related operating losses in the first half of 2026 against $195m in other operating expenses.
Live updates on NewsFeeds:BitcoinDesk editor: Keshav Aggarwal (accountable for this page; this summary was not edited by hand)
How this was produced: an AI model wrote this summary of Bitcoin.com News’s report, which we credit and link above. Read our Editorial and AI policy. Spotted a mistake? See Corrections.
Not investment advice. Read the risk disclaimer.